7 min read
Do you really need a caddie in Scotland?
On blind shots, local knowledge and the one course where we'd insist.

You don't need a caddie to play golf in Scotland.
Most courses are perfectly playable without one, and there's something quite enjoyable about carrying your own bag around an old links and working things out as you go.
But there are also courses where the person standing next to you knows something you don't.
They know that the bunker you can see isn't the problem. They know your perfectly struck drive needs to finish 30 yards further left than seems sensible. They know the putt that looks straight has been confusing visitors for the past twenty years.
And, perhaps most importantly, a good Scottish caddie knows when to tell you all of this and when to let you get on with making a mess of things yourself.
Links golf isn't always obvious
If most of your golf is played in America, there can be a short adjustment period when you arrive in Scotland.
The flag isn't necessarily where you should aim. A 150-yard shot might require a pitching wedge or a five iron depending on what the wind is doing. The best route to the green can involve deliberately hitting the ball away from it.
Then there are the blind shots.
At somewhere like North Berwick, you might find a stone wall sitting directly between you and where you want the ball to go. At Prestwick, some holes make considerably more sense once somebody has explained what is happening on the other side of the dunes.
You can work it out yourself.
A caddie just saves you doing so after the ball has disappeared.
Local knowledge is more than yardages
Nobody really needs another person to tell them they've got 164 yards.
Your watch can do that.
The useful stuff is knowing what 164 yards actually means on that particular piece of ground.
A caddie who walks the same links every week knows where the ball kicks, which bunkers you absolutely cannot visit and how much slower a putt becomes when you're putting back into the wind.
They'll also start learning your game surprisingly quickly.
After four holes they'll know whether you're actually capable of carrying that bunker you've been staring at, even if you're still fairly confident you are.
That's useful information.
You also get the stories
This is probably the part people underestimate.
A good caddie changes the atmosphere of a round.
They know the course, obviously, but they also know the club, the town and the people who have played there. You'll hear stories about famous rounds, terrible shots, visiting professionals and things that happened twenty years ago which may or may not have improved slightly in the retelling.
By the back nine, they also tend to know quite a lot about your group.
Who's playing for money. Who never buys a drink. Who claims not to care about their score and very clearly does.
That relationship is part of the experience, particularly on the old Scottish courses where caddies have been part of the place for generations.
We wouldn't take one everywhere
If we were playing five rounds in Scotland, we probably wouldn't book caddies for all five.
Partly because you don't need them, but also because golf experiences are better with a little variety.
There are days when we'd want the full thing: caddies on the first tee, a proper match between the group and someone keeping everyone moving in roughly the right direction.
Then there are courses where we'd rather carry a half set, buy a yardage book and disappear for three hours.
Shiskine on Arran is a good example. Twelve holes, spectacular scenery and enough eccentricity to make you smile your way around it. We'd rather not overcomplicate that.
Elie can be similar. Some golf is best enjoyed by simply playing it.
At Prestwick, we'd seriously consider one
Prestwick is exactly the sort of golf course where local knowledge earns its keep.
This is the birthplace of The Open, but it isn't preserved as some perfectly logical modern championship layout. There are blind shots, railway lines, huge bunkers and holes moving through wonderfully eccentric links terrain.
Some of the lines don't immediately make sense.
That's the fun of Prestwick, but it's also why we'd want somebody alongside us who has seen the course a thousand times before.
You could absolutely play it without a caddie.
You'd just understand several holes considerably better the second time around.
But there's one place where we'd insist
The Old Course.
If we've gone to the trouble of getting you onto the first tee at St Andrews, we're getting you a caddie too.
Part of that is practical. The Old Course is full of subtleties that aren't particularly obvious the first time you see it. Enormous shared greens, hidden bunkers, unusual angles and fairways where the correct line can look completely wrong from the tee.
A good caddie knows all of it.
But we'd insist for another reason too.
Playing the Old Course for the first time isn't an ordinary round of golf. You've probably travelled a long way to be there. You may only play it once in your life.
Walking across the Swilcan Bridge with someone who's spent years carrying bags around the place is part of the experience.
So is standing on the Road Hole tee while your caddie points towards a hotel and tells you to hit your drive over a building.
You don't get many tee shots like that at home.
The best caddies know when to disappear
There is a danger of making caddies sound like some sort of golfing satnav.
The good ones aren't.
They'll give you a line when you need one, talk you out of something particularly stupid and read a putt when asked. But they also understand that you're in Scotland with your friends and the round belongs to you.
Some holes require advice. Some require a story.
Others require everyone to stop talking for a minute and look at where they are.
That's probably the difference between having somebody carry your clubs and having a great caddie.
So, do you need one?
No.
But we'd have one for some of the rounds that matter most.
On a week through Scotland, we might use caddies at St Andrews, Prestwick or another major links where local knowledge adds something significant, then leave you to your own devices elsewhere.
It isn't about making the trip more luxurious.
It's about making certain rounds better.
And if we've managed to secure you an Old Course tee time, you can consider the argument settled.
We're booking the caddie.


